The answer depends primarily on the worker’s tax residence and the country in which the work is physically performed. Having an employment contract with a Spanish company or receiving a salary from Spain does not, by itself, mean that the entire salary must be taxed in Spain. When someone works from the Netherlands, the domestic rules of both countries and the double taxation treaty between Spain and the Netherlands must be reviewed.

Binding Tax Ruling V3326-23, dated 28 December 2023, examines a specific case involving remote work from the Netherlands for a Spanish company. Its criteria help structure the analysis, but they do not replace an individual assessment. The length of the stay, available accommodation, personal and economic ties, days worked in each country and the employer’s obligations may all affect the outcome.

Quick answer: a Spanish employment contract does not determine where tax is paid

To determine where someone working remotely from the Netherlands for a Spanish company should pay tax, at least three questions must be answered:

  1. Where is the individual tax resident during the calendar year?
  2. In which country is the work that generates the salary physically performed?
  3. Which country may tax the income under the Spain-Netherlands double taxation treaty?

If the individual is tax resident in Spain, the starting point is taxation in Spain on worldwide income, subject to the treaty and the applicable relief from double taxation. If the individual is tax resident in the Netherlands, Spain may only tax income regarded as Spanish-source income over which Spain retains taxing rights under the treaty.

The analysis does not end with personal income tax. The company should also review payroll withholding, social security, possible registration requirements in the Netherlands and, depending on the employee’s duties and the permanence of the arrangement, other corporate tax risks.

 

More information

 

The remote-working case examined in Binding Tax Ruling V3326-23

The ruling concerns an individual who moved to the Netherlands because of the individual’s spouse’s employment and continued to provide services remotely for a Spanish company. The employment contract had been entered into in Spain and a remote-working agreement was in place.

The ruling addresses three principal issues: the individual’s tax residence, the taxation of employment income and the obligation to file a tax return. The Spanish Directorate-General for Taxation begins with tax residence because that classification determines whether Spain taxes worldwide income through Spanish Personal Income Tax, known as IRPF, or only certain Spanish-source income through Non-Resident Income Tax, known as IRNR.

This sequence matters. Before calculating withholding or deciding where a salary must be reported, the relevant facts should be established: departure and return dates, physical presence, accommodation, the centre of personal and economic interests and the number of working days in each country.

How is tax residence in Spain determined?

The Spanish Tax Agency states that an individual is habitually resident in Spain when any of the following circumstances applies:

  • The individual remains in Spain for more than 183 days during the calendar year. Sporadic absences are included unless tax residence in another country can be demonstrated.
  • The main centre or base of the individual’s activities or economic interests is located in Spain, directly or indirectly.
  • Unless rebutted, there is a presumption of Spanish residence when the individual’s legally non-separated spouse and dependent minor children habitually reside in Spain.

The 183-day threshold is important, but it is not the only test. A person may spend a substantial part of the year outside Spain and still require an assessment of the main centre of activities or economic interests. Equally, having a Spanish employment contract does not automatically determine tax residence.

Evidence is critical. Tax residence certificates, travel records, tenancy agreements, family circumstances, the location of assets and sources of income, and other objective evidence may be required to support the position taken.

If the individual remains tax resident in Spain

An individual who is tax resident in Spain is generally subject to Spanish Personal Income Tax on worldwide income. This includes employment income even when the work is performed from another country or the payer is located in Spain.

However, worldwide taxation in Spain does not necessarily prevent the Netherlands from taxing the income. The country where employment is physically exercised may have the right to tax the salary under the treaty. If both countries tax the same income, the relevant double-taxation relief mechanism must be applied.

Spanish payroll withholding should therefore not be maintained automatically without checking the actual circumstances. Withholding is a payment on account and does not, by itself, determine the final tax position. Incorrect withholding can lead to excessive payments, later adjustments or cash-flow difficulties for the employee.

If the individual is tax resident in the Netherlands

If the individual is tax resident in the Netherlands, the individual will generally be taxable in Spain as a non-resident only on Spanish-source income that Spain is entitled to tax under domestic law and the treaty.

Binding Tax Ruling V3326-23 highlights that when the work is physically performed from the Netherlands, the employment is exercised there. Payment by a Spanish company does not automatically turn that work into employment exercised in Spain. If part of the work is performed in person in Spain, that portion requires a separate assessment.

It is also necessary to determine whether the income is subject to withholding in Spain and whether an IRNR return must be filed. The answer depends on whether Spain retains the right to tax the income and whether the corresponding withholding or payment on account has been made. A general conclusion should not be applied without reviewing the actual working days and locations.

What happens if Spain and the Netherlands both regard the individual as resident?

A dual-residence conflict may arise when the domestic law of both countries treats the same individual as tax resident. In that situation, the tie-breaker rules in the Spain-Netherlands treaty apply.

The treaty considers the following criteria in sequence:

  1. Permanent home. The first question is in which country the individual has a permanent home available.
  2. Centre of vital interests. If there is a permanent home in both countries, the individual’s closer personal and economic relations are considered.
  3. Habitual abode. If the previous test is inconclusive, the country in which the individual habitually lives is considered.
  4. Nationality. If the individual has a habitual abode in both countries or in neither country, nationality is considered.
  5. Mutual agreement. If the preceding tests do not resolve the matter, the competent authorities must settle it by agreement.

The individual cannot simply select the most favourable test. The criteria are applied in order and by reference to verifiable facts. The move should therefore be documented from the outset rather than only after a tax enquiry begins.

Where is remote-working salary taxed?

For cross-border remote work, the relevant place for employment income is generally the place where the employment is physically exercised. This makes it essential to distinguish between tax residence and the source or physical location of the work.

Situation What needs to be reviewed
All work performed from the Netherlands Tax residence, Dutch taxing rights and application of the treaty.
Work divided between the Netherlands and Spain Actual working days in each country and a possible allocation of remuneration.
Tax residence in Spain Spanish Personal Income Tax on worldwide income and relief from any double taxation.
Tax residence in the Netherlands Spanish Non-Resident Income Tax only on income Spain is entitled to tax.
Salary paid from Spain The payer’s country does not replace the residence and work-location analysis.

The treatment may also differ if the move is temporary, if an international mobility policy applies, if the individual works for different group companies, or if the individual has authority to negotiate or conclude contracts. These circumstances may affect both the employee and the company.

What should the Spanish company review before authorising remote work?

The employee’s personal tax position is only one part of the analysis. A Spanish company allowing regular work from the Netherlands should coordinate its tax, employment, payroll and international mobility teams.

  • Withholding and payroll: determine whether Spanish withholding should continue, be adjusted or cease, and whether Dutch payroll obligations arise.
  • Social security: identify the applicable legislation and required documentation. Tax residence and social security affiliation are separate questions.
  • Employer registration: assess whether the employee’s presence creates registration or reporting obligations in the Netherlands.
  • Permanent establishment: consider the duration, whether the workplace is at the company’s disposal, the employee’s duties and any authority to negotiate or conclude contracts.
  • Remote-working agreement: document the authorised country, duration, duties, work equipment, data protection requirements and return conditions.
  • Internal policy: establish a request, review, approval and monitoring process to avoid isolated decisions.

Employment approval to work from another country does not automatically resolve the tax or social security implications. Each area has its own rules and may require separate action.

For a broader overview, read our guide to the legal, tax and employment aspects of international remote work. For the company’s tax exposure, see corporate taxation and international remote work.

Documents and steps required to review the case

Before taking a tax position, we recommend preparing a file containing the relevant facts:

  1. Exact departure, arrival and travel dates for each country.
  2. A calendar of days physically worked in Spain and the Netherlands.
  3. The employment contract and remote-working agreement.
  4. Homes available in both countries.
  5. Family circumstances and personal ties.
  6. Sources of income, assets and main economic interests.
  7. Available tax residence certificates.
  8. Payroll records, withholding and tax returns already filed.
  9. Duties, clients, representation powers and contracting authority.
  10. Social security coverage and supporting documents.

This information can be used to prepare a matrix covering residence, salary taxation, withholding, filing requirements, social security and corporate risks. The analysis should be updated if the circumstances change during the year.

Do you need to review an international remote-working arrangement?

At Adlanter, we help companies and professionals assess the tax implications of cross-border work, coordinate the obligations of the employee and employer, and reduce the risk of double taxation or non-compliance. Our team can review tax residence, salary taxation, withholding and assignment documentation as part of a coordinated solution.

Learn about our tax and accounting advisory services for companies or explore our international mobility services.

This content is for information only. Legislation, administrative criteria and personal circumstances may change. Each case should be validated before filing tax returns or modifying payroll withholding.

Nuestros expertos

  • Adlanter

    Expertos en asesoría fiscal, laboral, mercantil, contable, movilidad internacional y gestión del talento. Compartimos análisis, novedades normativas y contenido especializado para ayudar a empresas y profesionales a tomar decisiones informadas y afrontar con seguridad los retos de un entorno empresarial en constante evolución.

Do you have any questions?

If you have any questions after reading "Working remotely from the Netherlands for a Spanish company: where do you pay tax?", we are here to help you.

Let's talk. We guide you clearly and step by step.

Contact us now