Objective Hiring: How to Avoid Bias in Recruitment Processes

Finding the right candidate goes far beyond simply filling a vacancy. In an environment where talent is scarce and hiring decisions have a direct impact on business direction, recruitment becomes a critical process.

Still, many selection processes are influenced by unconscious biases that compromise objectivity and steer us away from the true goal: hiring the person who best fits the role and adds value to the team from day one.

As Carles Bonastre, Director of Talent Solutions at Adlanter, states:
“Objectivity is key to successful hiring.”

What Are Cognitive Biases?

Cognitive biases are mental shortcuts our brain uses to process information quickly. While useful in everyday life, they can lead to poor hiring decisions when based on subjective perceptions instead of objective facts.

 

Want more information

The Most Common Biases in Recruitment

Here are the most frequent ones, with real-world examples:

Affinity Bias

We tend to feel more comfortable with people similar to us. This might create immediate rapport with candidates who studied at the same university, share similar interests, or come from a familiar background. But beware: this doesn’t always mean they’re the best fit for the role.

Projection Bias

We assume the candidate thinks like us, shares our values, or would act similarly in certain situations. This bias can limit team diversity and depth.

Confirmation Bias

We focus on information that confirms what we already believe about a candidate—while ignoring the rest. For instance, if someone has spoken highly of a candidate, we may unconsciously seek signs that reinforce that opinion.

Halo Effect

One positive trait—such as strong communication skills—may cause us to overestimate the candidate in other areas not yet assessed.

Horn Effect

The opposite occurs here: a single negative trait (like a typo on the CV) can overshadow the candidate’s strengths.

Primacy and Recency Bias

We tend to remember the first and last candidates of the day better, which may skew objectivity when comparing profiles.

Contrast Effect

We judge one candidate based on the level of the previous ones. If a prior interviewee was exceptional, the next may seem weaker—even if fully qualified.

Strategies to Reduce Bias and Make Objective Hiring Decisions

Integrating specific measures into recruitment processes not only improves results but also enhances fairness and employer reputation.

• Use Structured Interviews
  Creating a consistent set of questions for all candidates ensures you’re evaluating with the same criteria, reducing subjectivity.

• Apply Competency-Based Assessments
  Supplement interviews with exercises, technical tests, or objective reasoning challenges to gather more impartial data.

• Form Diverse Interview Panels
  Including interviewers with different perspectives helps counterbalance individual biases.

• Train Interviewers
  Training in cognitive bias awareness is essential for recruiters to recognize and reduce their influence.

• Involve External Professionals
  Delegating the process or adding an external expert at key stages can increase fairness and technical precision.

Frequently Asked Questions on Objectivity in Hiring

Can bias be completely eliminated from interviews?

Not entirely—but it can be significantly reduced through structured, conscious, and professional approaches.

Are psychometric tests useful for reducing bias?

Yes, provided they’re well-designed and validated. They offer objective data to contrast against subjective impressions.

Does a diverse interview panel improve objectivity?

Absolutely. The more diverse the panel, the lower the chance a single bias will influence the final decision.

How can I tell if my company uses objective hiring practices?

Check if you have structured interview guides, defined evaluation criteria, regular training, and frequent reviews of hiring outcomes.

Related Content: The Most In-Demand Job Profiles in 2025

✅ How Adlanter Can Help

At Adlanter, we have a team of experts in executive, technical, and middle management recruitment. We bring objective methodologies, cross-sector experience, and legal-strategic insight to ensure accurate and sustainable hiring.

If you’re building your team or want to assess whether your selection process aligns with best practices, explore our recruitment services or get in touch with our specialists. We’ll help you make decisions based on real talent and data.